Category: verdicts-and-settlements

Jacksonville Attorney Obtains Defense Verdict in Trucking Case

Posted in Verdicts and Settlements on February 17, 2022

John Viggiani, Managing Partner in the firm’s Jacksonville office, obtained a defense verdict for our trucking company client and its driver in a 3 day jury trial in Jacksonville, Florida.  The defense admitted responsibility for causing the accident which involved the defendant driver backing up and hitting the front of the Plaintiff’s vehicle while she was stopped in traffic.  The Plaintiff claimed to have crushed her left foot in the accident and to have subsequently developed Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy/Complex Regional Pain Syndrome.  Both of the Plaintiff’s treating physicians indicated the injury to her foot and subsequent problems were caused by the accident and developed over the 5 and ½ years following the accident. Neither of Plaintiff’s doctors were provided or aware of the Plaintiff going to the Emergency Room 3 days after the accident and their being no indication of any injury or problem with her left foot. 

Read More

Fort Myers Partners Obtain Defense Verdict in a Premises Liability Personal Injury Lawsuit

Posted in Verdicts and Settlements on February 16, 2022

Cristobal Casal and Yasmine Kirollos, both partners in the Fort Myers office, obtained a defense verdict in a premises liability personal injury lawsuit involving a slip and fall at a Naples hotel.  The hotel was sued under allegations that it allowed a dangerous condition to exist on an exterior staircase on which the Plaintiff alleged that he slipped and fell.  Plaintiff was an out-of-town guest who claimed that the hotel’s air conditioning units were leaking water out onto the exterior walkway which then made its way onto the staircase resulting in algae and mold developing on the steps over time.  Defendant denied that any such condition existed on the steps or the walkway.  

Read More

Orlando Attorney Obtains Favorable Verdict in a Case Involving a Rear-End Collision with Admitted Liability

Posted in Verdicts and Settlements on February 11, 2022

Orlando partner Rod Lundy secured a favorable verdict for our defendant company and its driver in Lake County following a 5 day trial.  The defense admitted liability for the rear-end collision, which was captured on the company’s onboard video system.  

Read More

First Party Defense Verdict Obtained in a Hurricane Michael Trial

Posted in Verdicts and Settlements on December 2, 2021

Michael Bonfanti and Joshua Canton, partners in the firm’s Tallahassee office, obtained a defense verdict in a Hurricane Michael first party property case tried over three days in Bay County, Florida.  The Plaintiffs argued at trial that their home was a total loss due to structural damage to the pilings by the hurricane. The Defendant argued that the home had no structural damage, was repairable, and that the Defendant had already paid its insureds the reasonable costs to repair the home prior to litigation. The jury awarded $0.00 for repair of the home. The Plaintiffs also failed to secure a verdict above the expired exclusive Proposals for Settlement served upon each Plaintiff, thus entitling the Defendant to recover its attorney’s fees.  

Read More

Partners Tom McCausland and John Viggiani Obtain Favorable Verdict in an Admitted Liability Accident

Posted in Verdicts and Settlements on November 18, 2021

Thomas J. McCausland and John Viggiani, Partners in the firm recently obtained a favorable verdict in a 5 day jury trial in an admitted liability motor vehicle accident case in Jacksonville, Florida. The case involved a rear-end accident on northbound I-95 during stop and go traffic. The Plaintiff was driving a pick-up truck and pulling a travel trailer headed to Virginia. The Defendant driver was operating a company box truck and hit the rear of the travel trailer. Plaintiff did not go to the hospital and continued on with his trip to Virginia to pick up his wife. He was there a couple of days and then returned back to the Orlando area. At no time did the Plaintiff seek medical care or treatment. The Plaintiff's first medical care was 13 days after the accident.

Read More